Beacons vs Gumroad: The Simple & Honest Review for Creators
I remember just staring at my computer screen. In one tab, I had Beacons. In the other, Gumroad. My brain felt like it was turning into mush.
They both look so good! They both say they will help me, a creator, make money from my stuff. But which one is right?
It’s a big question, and I spent so much time trying to figure it out.
Beacons: Your All-in-One Best Friend
The Cool Stuff Beacons Can Do (Its Features)
Link-in-Bio Builder: This is the heart of Beacons. It’s a page builder that is super easy to use. It’s like playing with building blocks. You drag a block for a link, you drop in a block for a video. You can change the colors and fonts to make it look exactly like you. And it’s made to look great on a phone, which is important because most of our fans are on their phones. Digital Storefront: This is HUGE. You can build a little shop right on your Beacons page. You can sell your digital products—like eBooks, photo presets, guides, templates, anything! You can also book appointments if you are a coach, or even just let your fans give you a tip or a donation. A really cool part: on the free plan, you can list an UNLIMITED number of products. That is very generous. Email Marketing: Beacons has a tool to help you talk to your fans. You can put a little box on your page that says “Join my email list!” When people sign up, you can send them emails. You can send a welcome email, a weekly newsletter, or an email to tell them about a new product you made. If you pay for a bigger plan, you can send unlimited emails and even set up automatic email series. Audience Manager (CRM): This sounds complicated, but it’s not. CRM is just a list of your fans and customers. Beacons keeps a list for you. You can see who bought what, who clicked which link, and who is a super fan. You can even add little tags to people, like “Loves my art” or “Bought my course.” This helps you send the right messages to the right people. Analytics Dashboard: This is your report card. It shows you how many people visited your page, which links they clicked, how much money you made, and where your visitors came from (like Instagram or TikTok). This information is gold. It helps you understand what is working and what is not. Media Kit: If you want to work with brands, you need a media kit. It’s like a resume for your creator business. Beacons helps you make a simple one that shows brands your stats and how many followers you have. It makes you look super professional. AI-Powered Tools: This is the future, and it’s a big deal in the beacons ai vs gumroad discussion. Beacons has some Artificial Intelligence helpers. It has an AI that can help you write emails to brands. It has another AI that can help you create a digital product. You give it an idea for a mini-course or a guide, and it writes a first draft for you. This can save you SO much time. More Power with Paid Plans: If you decide to pay for Beacons, you unlock even more stuff. You can get a custom domain name (so it looks like yourname.com instead of beacons.ai/yourname). You can sell full online courses and memberships, and you can sync multiple calendars for your appointments. The biggest plan even gives you a special person to help you set everything up.
Who is Beacons For?
Gumroad: The Simple, Powerful Shopkeeper
The Great Stuff Gumroad Can Do (Its Features)
Supports Many Product Types: This is where Gumroad really, really shines. You can sell almost any kind of digital thing you can imagine. Ebooks, music, digital art, video courses, templates… you name it. But it also has special powers. You can sell software and Gumroad will automatically create unique license keys for each customer! This is a huge deal for developers. You can also sell different versions of a product (like a PDF, an ePub, and a Kindle version of your book) at different prices. It even lets you sell physical things, but most people use it for digital. Customizable Shop Page: You get your own storefront on Gumroad. You can change the colors and add a background image to make it your own. But Gumroad is also very flexible. If you already have your own website or blog, you can just embed a Gumroad “buy” button right on your site. So people can buy from you without ever leaving your website. It’s very seamless. Flexible Payment Choices: Memberships & Subscriptions: You can easily set up recurring payments. Maybe you have a private newsletter or a library of content that people pay for every month or every year. Gumroad makes this easy. Pay What You Want: I love this feature. You can let your customers choose the price they want to pay for a product. You can set a minimum (like "$5+"), but it’s a great way to be generous and sometimes, people will surprise you and pay more! Accept Money from Anywhere: Gumroad lets you sell to people all over the world in their own currency. This is very important for a global audience. VAT Handling: This is a lifesaver. If you sell to customers in the European Union, there is a special tax called VAT. The rules are very confusing. Gumroad automatically handles all of this for you. It calculates the tax, collects it, and pays it to the EU. You don’t have to do anything. This alone is worth so much.
Marketing Tools: Email Marketing: Gumroad also has email tools. You can send updates (they call them "posts") to all your customers or followers on Gumroad. You can also set up automatic email sequences, like a 7-day course delivered by email. Affiliate Program: You can set up your own affiliate team. This means your fans or other creators can share a special link to your product. If someone buys through their link, they get a small percentage of the sale. It’s a great way to get more people to promote your work. Discover Feature: Gumroad has its own marketplace where it recommends products to its users. For an extra fee, you can get your product featured there. This can help new people who have never heard of you find your work.
Protecting Your Work: Gumroad offers simple ways to protect your digital files, like stamping a PDF with the buyer’s email address. This helps discourage people from sharing it illegally.
Who is Gumroad For?
The Big Comparison: Beacons vs Gumroad
The Main Idea: Hub vs. Shop
Let’s Talk About Money: The Fees
Free Plan ($0/month): You can build your page and sell unlimited products, but Beacons takes a 9% transaction fee from every sale. Creator Pro Plan ($10/month): You get more features like a custom domain, but Beacons still takes that 9% transaction fee. Store Pro Plan ($30/month): This is the magic level. It costs $30 a month, but the transaction fee goes down to 0%. ZERO! You only pay the standard payment processor fee (like from Stripe or PayPal). This plan also unlocks courses and memberships. Business Pro Plan ($90/month): This is for big agencies and brands, with extra support. Also 0% fees.
One Plan ($0/month): There is no monthly fee to use Gumroad. Ever. But, for every sale, Gumroad takes a 10% transaction fee. On top of that, there are the payment processing fees from Stripe or PayPal (usually around 3-4%).
Which one is cheaper?
On Gumroad, they take 10%. so that's 40 plus payment processing fees. you probably pay around $55 - $60 in fees.
On Beacons’ Store Pro plan, you pay the flat $30 for the month. That’s it. You just saved $25!
Who Wins on Features?
For Selling a Variety of Things: Gumroad wins if you sell weird or technical stuff like software with license keys. It’s built for that. For Building a Community: Beacons wins here. Its built-in CRM and audience tools are more powerful for understanding and talking to your audience in a deep way. For Getting Help from AI: Beacons, for sure. The AI tools are unique to Beacons and can be a massive help. This is a key part of the beacons ai vs gumroad debate. For Global Selling: Gumroad has a big advantage with its automatic VAT handling and multi-currency support. It makes selling internationally much less scary. For Working with Brands: Beacons wins with its built-in Media Kit feature. For Getting Help from Others: Gumroad wins with its built-in affiliate program.
So, Who Should You Choose? My Final Advice
You are a social media creator (TikTok, Instagram, YouTube). Your audience is on those platforms, and you need a central home for them to go to. You want to have many ways to make money from one place: sell products, book coaching calls, get tips, and find brand deals. You want to build a deep relationship with your audience using a built-in CRM and email tools. You plan to sell more than $400 a month and want to save money on fees by paying a monthly subscription.
You are a product-focused creator. You make amazing ebooks, art, music, or software, and you just need the best, simplest way to sell it. You already have an audience on a blog or email list and just need to plug in a "buy" button. You want to sell internationally and not have to worry about complicated VAT taxes. You want to start for free with absolutely no monthly bill, and you are okay with the 10% fee. You need special features like software license keys.